Sunday, June 01, 2008

Mary, Called Magdalene, Book Review

Mary, Called Magdalene Mary, Called Magdalene by Margaret George


My review


rating: 3 of 5 stars
While this is a fascinating book in terms of the historical details of daily life in the first century, I have to disagree with the review in Publisher's Weekly which states that it "imagines nothing seriously objectionable to even the most devout Christians." That isn't true if one counts Catholics as "devout Christians".

First of all, the book's portrayal of Mary, the Mother of Jesus is problematic for Catholics. It portrays her as joining Jesus' siblings (another problematic interpretation) in doubting Jesus when he begins his mission, only joining the Apostles later.

The other disturbing thing is that Jesus doesn't seem to know he is the Messiah until right before he goes to Jerusalem for the final time. The book seems to go out of its way to portray Jesus as very much "only human". There is no sense that He is the second person of the Blessed Trinity here at all.

I will update this when I get to the end of the book. I'm wondering how or if the Resurrection will be portrayed.

Update: While the post-resurrection portion was decidedly supernatural (as opposed to walking the line between Jesus as a weird-but-good man and something "more") the entire book was an odd marriage of Fundamentalism and Feminism. Mary Magdalene is portrayed throughout the story as equal to (and in some ways a bit above and apart from) the (male) Apostles. Also, the author seems to make a point of having the Mary Magdalene discuss whether or not Peter has primacy over the other Apostles(one can perhaps guess the answer here)and there is a point near the end where it is declared that the Church "has no doctrine."

So, while the book is intriguing, it is in no way in line with historical Christianity as expressed by the Catholic Church.

View all my reviews.

4 comments:

Marilena said...

i made a new Catholic prayer blog at wordpress. it can be found here:
http://prayersforourlady.wordpress.com/

stop by if you like and add a comment:)

Marie said...

I have never understood the thought that many Christians think that Jesus had no idea of who he was? If that is the case what was he doing in the Temple speaking words of such Wisdom that it amazed all?

Good points Dymphna:).

Peace to you:)

Marie

Dymphna (4HisChurch) said...

Well, I can't understand how someone can be God and not realize it!

Shirley said...

Why would you give this book, which seems to be a corruption of the truth as taught by the Catholic church,3 stars? Personally, I'd throw it in the dumpster!

Dymphna's favorite quotes


"Slavery ended in medieval Europe only because the church extended its sacraments to all slaves and then managed to impose a ban on the enslavement of Christians (and of Jews). Within the context of medieval Europe, that prohibition was effectively a rule of universal abolition. "— Rodney Stark

my poetry on the web

Karumi Garden

Karumi Garden
my haiku